Benjamin Moore Colonial Cream vs. Sherwin Williams Butter Up

The colors, each unique in their hue and saturation, embody their own individual beauty and value. The hues of the colors are quite similar.
Sherwin Williams SW 6681 is more saturated than Colonial Cream
They differ in their values, Benjamin Moore OC-77 radiating a lighter essence compared to SW 6681.

Supported paint brands for comparison: Behr, Benjamin Moore, Farrow and Ball, Dulux, Jotun, Little Greene, NCS, Ral Classic, Ral Design, Ral Effect, Sherwin Williams, Valspar, Tikkurila

First color

Second color

Benjamin Moore Colonial Cream vs. Sherwin Williams Butter Up
Technical color comparison for Benjamin Moore Colonial Cream and Sherwin Williams Butter Up
Benjamin Moore Colonial CreamSherwin Williams Butter Up
Shared hue scale
12
Hue
35°orange42°orange
Saturation
64%82%more saturated
Lightness?Simple 0–100% measure derived from the minimum and maximum sRGB channels. Use CIE L* for perceptual lightness.
91%80%darker
LRV?Light Reflectance Value measures the percentage of light reflected by a color, from 0 for absolute black to 100 for pure white.
81.9673.80looks darker
CIE L?Perceptual lightness. CIE Lab lightness ranges from 0 for black to 100 for diffuse white.
93.5688.9looks darker
Color difference ΔE*₀₀?CIE color difference. Smaller is closer: about 0–1 is imperceptible, 1–2 just noticeable, 2–5 a small difference, 5–10 clear, and more than 10 very different.
11.864
Temperature
WarmWarm
Preview Colonial Cream and Butter Up side by side in different rooms

Please note that the color shown on this page is a representation and might not exactly match the real shade of the cards, fan decks, or color collections. Your monitor, browser, and screen angle can all affect how the paint looks, so it may not be the same as what you see here. All information on this page is based on RGB and HEX values provided by manufacturers.

It's important to keep in mind that the same color may appear differently on various surfaces due to the nature of those surfaces. For example, the same shade will look different on a rough wall compared to the smooth surface of cabinets.

Try before you buy

Samplize samples on the wall

100% accurate
reusable paint samples

Peel, stick and repeat

Peel, stick,
and repeat

Twice painted samples

Twice painted
with real paint

Fast delivery

Next day
delivery

Shop now

Color comparisons featuring Benjamin Moore Colonial Cream

Colonial Cream and Pale Oak comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs OC-20 Pale Oak

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Montgomery White comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs OC-148 Montgomery White

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Sweet Bluette comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 813 Sweet Bluette

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Pale Almond comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs OC-2 Pale Almond

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Sand Dunes comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 1072 Sand Dunes

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Divine White comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW6105 Divine White

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Kestrel White comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW7516 Kestrel White

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Bleached Linen comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs PPU5-09 Bleached Linen

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Tallow comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 203 Tallow

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Woodland Snow comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 2161-70 Woodland Snow

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Aphrodite Pink comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 895 Aphrodite Pink

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Venetian Crystal 6 comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 10BB 43/206 Venetian Crystal 6

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Gobi Desert comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 2110-50 Gobi Desert

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Dix Blue comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 82 Dix Blue

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Venetian Marble comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 2114-70 Venetian Marble

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Eider White comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW7014 Eider White

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Philadelphia Cream comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs HC-30 Philadelphia Cream

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Essex Green comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs HC-188 Essex Green

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Shoji White comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW7042 Shoji White

long arrow
Colonial Cream and White Duck comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW7010 White Duck

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Lancaster Whitewash comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs HC-174 Lancaster Whitewash

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Natural Cream comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs OC-14 Natural Cream

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Saybrook Sage comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs HC-114 Saybrook Sage

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Evening Sun comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 3004-6C Evening Sun

long arrow
Colonial Cream and White Flour comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs OR-W10 White Flour

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Warm Beige comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW0035 Warm Beige

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Hathaway Peach comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs HC-53 Hathaway Peach

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Frosted Toffee comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 988 Frosted Toffee

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Apricot Ice comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 2001-2C Apricot Ice

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Pashmina comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs AF-100 Pashmina

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Spanish White comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs OC-35 Spanish White

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Banana Cream comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 275 Banana Cream

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Peach Parfait comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs 2175-70 Peach Parfait

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Maison Blanche comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW7526 Maison Blanche

long arrow
Colonial Cream and Vaguely Mauve comparison

OC-77 Colonial Cream vs SW6015 Vaguely Mauve

long arrow